- Air traffic control needs a major rethink
- The “$30 Billion ATC bill”
- Arm’s-length ATC/safety regulator merits
- First US remote/digital control towers
- Canada’s long-term airport leases
- News notes
- Quotable quotes
Air Traffic Control Needs a Major Rethink
Simply put: Friday’s nationwide aviation ground stop, triggered by an overloaded router, should not have happened. Transportation Secretary Sean Duffy blamed a contractor and defended the Federal Aviation Administration, saying it’s working hard on modernization despite the glitch that triggered massive delays and cancellations that some travelers, airlines and airports are still dealing with.
“I don’t take any responsibility,” President Donald Trump added today.
The fact that Duffy and Trump are passing the buck, and that FAA is still gradually replacing copper wire with fiber cables, illustrates the agency’s inherent problems as a tax-funded, politically micromanaged government agency that provides and regulates air traffic control.
Worldwide as of 2026, more than 90 countries receive their air traffic management from stand-alone air navigation service providers (ANSPs) that are self-supported via air traffic control user fees. Many of those ANSPs have bonding authority, which means they can issue long-term revenue bonds to finance large-scale capital improvements. In countries whose ANSPs are supported largely or entirely by aviation user fees, major modernizations are financed through those revenue streams.
Nearly all well-run U.S. public utilities can issue revenue bonds to finance large modernization programs, backed by revenue from customers who pay their electric, gas, and water bills to the utilities. Air traffic control should be treated as a utility.
Instead, today’s FAA is a cobbled-together entity that is both the aviation safety regulator and the provider of air traffic control services. That is a flawed model, considered bad practice by the International Civil Aviation Organization (ICAO), which recommends separating the aviation safety regulator from the operation and management of airports and air traffic control. While most industrial countries properly separate those roles, the United States is one of the few major countries that ignores ICAO’s recommendation on this subject.
Ironically, last week’s ground stop and the resulting air travel chaos occurred as Canada celebrated the 30th anniversary of Nav Canada, its well-run, well-financed ANSP. Nav Canada’s safety is looked after by a Canadian government entity that is at arm’s length from Nav Canada, consistent with ICAO policy. Thanks to its bondable revenue stream and business approach, Nav Canada replaced paper flight strips with electronic strips in less than two years, rather than FAA’s planned 15-year rollout.
My Reason Foundation colleague Marc Scribner has an excellent op-ed in The Wall Street Journal today. He critiques the current policy of our air traffic control system being embedded in a safety regulatory agency, instead of being regulated at arm’s length as is standard practice in nearly 100 countries, and details how Canada solved its air traffic control shortcomings in 1996 by taking ATC out of Canada’s aviation safety regulator and converting it into a nonprofit, user-governed ANSP.
So, the United States does have a model for fixing our flawed and underfunded air traffic control system. The better model is there, right across our northern border in Canada.
The Phony $30 Billion Air Traffic Control Bill
Here is a headline from Politico Pro before this weekend’s ground stop and massive delays: “Duffy, White House, Ready Lobbying Blitz on $30B Air Traffic Control Request.”
Similar headlines have appeared in numerous other media outlets. Yet the $30 billion “Modern Skies” proposal is not even half dedicated to air traffic control. Here is how the proposed $30 billion would be allocated if the bill is enacted by Congress:
- $10 billion to upgrade three pre-selected airports’ terminals;
- $10 billion for reliable digital hardware for air traffic control; and
- $10 billion to overhaul outdated airport infrastructure, including control towers.
Air traffic control expert John Kefaliotis‘ Reason Foundation analysis of the bill points out that the pre-selected U.S. airports that would split $10 billion would provide far more than all other U.S. airports get from the $4 billion per year Airport Improvement Program (AIP) grants. It is grossly unfair for Congress to single out three airports to get huge windfalls compared with typical AIP grants. This is what used to be called “pork-barrel” legislation, and it’s unfair to the hundreds of other U.S. airports that get only modest help via AIP grants.
As Kefaliotis notes: “The airport terminals pilot program proposes to spend more than twice the normal AIP allotment without the AIP restrictions on what the money can be spent for and directs it specifically to airports that have failed to maintain their terminal infrastructure.”
He also flags: “It is not clear if any airports other than St. Louis Lambert International, in the home state of the bill’s sponsor, Sen. Eric Schmitt, would actually qualify.”
The bill’s proposed air traffic control (ATC) improvements are also open to question. The $10.1 billion in this portion of the bill would provide:
- $300 million for ATC facility consolidation;
- $600 million for strategic air traffic flow management technology;
- $2 billion for cloud computing infrastructure; and
- $7.2 billion for a common automation platform to replace FAA’s terminal and en route automation systems.
I won’t list all of Kefaliotis’s critiques, but I will raise several of my concerns. First, there is a serious need for large-scale air traffic control facility consolidation. Reason Foundation published my study on this in 2013. But $300 million is only a token amount for a serious nationwide facility consolidation program. FAA needs perhaps three high-altitude centers, not the current 21.
Kefaliotis terms the $2 billion for cloud computing as “simply egregious.” As he points out, “Centralizing process in the cloud [would] subject the system to widespread outages from cloud system failure.” He also notes that “an operational air traffic control automation platform serving significant air traffic has not been put in the cloud anywhere on earth.”
There is a lot more in his commentary, which I urge you to read. The Modern Skies Act won’t improve or modernize air traffic control in the ways being claimed.
More Countries Separate Air Traffic Control from Air Safety Regulator
The ground stop and air traffic control failure also remind us that housing a country’s air traffic control provider within its aviation safety regulator, as in the United States, is unwise.
Over the past 30 years, more governments have taken action to separate these two vital functions. Since 2001, ICAO policy has been that aviation safety should be organizationally separate from airports and air traffic control. Nearly 100 governments have carried out such separation, but the United States remains an outlier.
One such separation took place in 2023, when the Irish government created AirNav Ireland as the country’s designated air navigation service provider (ANSP). This transition made the new AirNav a self-supporting entity, generating its own revenue from aviation fees and charges (as do the large majority of ANSPs worldwide). Air Nav Ireland provides air traffic services across the North Atlantic (Shanwick Oceanic) as well as serving the airports of Cork, Dublin, and Shannon. The former Irish Aviation Authority was merged with the Commission for Aviation Regulation to form a single national aviation safety regulator. This important aviation reform had been urged by aviation stakeholders over several decades.
On a smaller scale, on Oct. 6, the government of Nepal announced its plan to split the Civil Aviation Authority of Nepal into two separate entities: one to handle air safety regulation and the other to operate and manage airports and air traffic control. Civil Aviation Minister Khadak Raj Paudel told Reuters that “Separating these functions will address inherent conflict of interest in the current structure and strengthen the credibility and effectiveness of safety oversight”. As of last month, the transition had not yet taken place, since it requires legislation by Nepal’s parliament.
In Reason Foundation’s 2026 Annual Aviation Infrastructure Report, my colleague Marc Scribner included a table of worldwide ANSPs by type of organization (Table 5), based on data from the Civil Air Navigation Services Organization (CANSO). Of the 96 countries listed, three obtain ATC services from corporations (Canada, Italy, and the UK). Another 67 ANSPs are government corporations such as Airservices Australia, Germany’s DFS, and Airways New Zealand. Another 23 are civil aviation authorities, usually part of a transport ministry that often includes aviation safety regulation. In addition, there are four intergovernmental entities that operate as multijurisdictional ANSPs. These are:
- Roberts Flight Information Region (ANSP for three African countries)
- MUAC providing high-altitude ANSP services for Belgium, Luxembourg, the Netherlands, and northwestern Germany
- COCENA providing ATC services for six Central American countries
- ASECNA providing ATC services for 17 African countries and two French overseas departments.
All four charge ICAO-based aviation user fees.
Overall, Reason Foundation counts 74 user-fee-supported ANSPs, but including the countries served by multi-country ANSPs, the total countries served by air traffic control corporations funded by aviation user fees is 96. Alas, the United States is not one of them.
First Remote/Digital Towers Deployed in the United States
By Marc Scribner
On Nov. 6, FAA announced that remote/digital air traffic control towers were now operational at two U.S. airports: Bartow Executive Airport in Florida and Kenai Municipal Airport in Alaska. The agency says five additional airports are planning to deploy the same technology, smartVISION from Austria’s Frequentis. This is great news, but the FAA still has a long way to go to catch up with its international counterparts in deploying remote/digital towers.
Remote/digital towers use cameras and other sensors to provide air traffic controllers with better visibility than the conventional method of looking out a tower window. They can see through darkness, rain, and fog, and multiple feeds can be stitched together and linked to other data to provide enhanced heads-up situational awareness. A control room can be set up in a standard building on the ground, either on site or many miles away. This can allow small airports to forgo the expense of constructing a special tower structure, which is often cost-prohibitive.
In addition to Bartow and Kenai airports, FAA says it is pursuing projects at Winter Haven Regional Airport in Florida, Venice Municipal Airport in Florida, Montgomery County Airpark in Maryland, Johnston Regional Airport in North Carolina, and Durango-La Plata County Airport in Colorado. Winter Haven is located 12 miles from Bartow, which would host the first remote tower center to control traffic at both airports.
These operational deployments followed system design approval of Frequentis’ smartVISION technology in September. Frequentis, which partnered with RTX (formerly Raytheon) for U.S. deployments, is the only approved remote/digital tower vendor in the United States. Currently, smartVISION is only approved for use when requested by an airport owner-operator as part of the Federal Contract Tower program, and only at single-runway airports. It is not approved for use by FAA itself, so commercial service airports in the United States cannot deploy remote/digital towers.
Remote/digital towers have been growing in popularity worldwide since the first system, developed by Saab, was deployed in Sweden in 2015. Last year, Reason Foundation published a report on remote/digital towers that included a survey on global deployments. By our count, there were 30 remote/digital towers in operation by early 2025, with dozens more projects in various stages of planning and development.
Interest in the technology is not limited to small airports. Since 2021, London City Airport has been controlled by a remote tower, which is located 80 miles away from its control center in Swanwick. Large commercial hubs such as Doha and Singapore have been exploring ways to augment traditional brick-and-mortar towers with digital tower technology.
In most of these various contexts, remote/digital tower deployment has been pursued by national air navigation service providers, while FAA has not announced plans to deploy and operate any of these potential configurations at its own facilities. Perhaps FAA is waiting for the U.S. remote/digital tower market to mature first at airports served by private providers under the Federal Contract Tower program. If this is the case, the agency needs to align with global best practices on system design approval to encourage entry by competing vendors.
Section 621 of the FAA Reauthorization Act of 2024 established the current remote tower program at FAA. This program received $50 million in supplemental funding from the One Big Beautiful Bill Act of 2025 to spur implementation by FAA. One requirement contained in Section 621 is that FAA must conduct system design approval evaluations at no fewer than three locations outside the FAA Technical Center in Atlantic City.
Conducting system design approval at the sponsor airports themselves could substantially reduce the costs and time required to deploy remote/digital towers. It could give additional technology providers—including Kongsberg, Saab, and Searidge—confidence to enter the U.S. market and seek approval from FAA. This could promote a virtuous cycle because a longer list of approved vendors could encourage more airports to sponsor remote/digital tower projects.
Beyond streamlining the system design approval process, another priority for FAA should be to leverage these initial seven projects into remote tower centers that can control traffic at multiple airfields from a single location. The upcoming Bartow Center is a good start, but FAA could actively promote these project opportunities to similar airports in the same regions.
FAA Administrator Bryan Bedford deserves praise for finally achieving remote/digital tower deployment in the United States. Special thanks are also owed to Sen. Ted Budd (R–N.C.), the author of the Section 621 program, and Senate Commerce Committee Chairman Ted Cruz (R–Texas), who provided critical support and oversight of the program. But realizing the full potential of remote/digital tower technology in the United States will require a lot more work.
Canada to Seek Long-Term P3 Concessions for Major Airports
An article in the September issue of the monthly newsletter Public Works Financing is titled “Canada Initiates Massive Airport Concession Program.” It quotes Prime Minister Mark Carney announcing that the government will “unlock the true value” of its four major airports by long-term leasing them to investors and airport management companies. He said the government will invest the billions of dollars raised from these leases for infrastructure needed for the next generation. Some details are provided in the current government budget.
The program applies to Canada’s four largest airports: Calgary International, Montreal Trudeau, Toronto Pearson, and Vancouver International. Fitch Ratings noted that these four airports carry approximately C$8 billion in long-term debt. The planned term for the airport P3 concessions is 40 to 50 years. The government expects the winners of long-term concessions to invest in improving the airports; it will also require a stake in each concession for the Canada Strong Fund and some kind of role for local Indigenous communities. Canada’s well-run public pension funds are very likely to be investors in the airport P3 concessions.
Fiscal proceeds from the airport concessions are to be reinvested in improvements to Canada’s overall aviation and infrastructure systems, including regional and local air transportation. Another potential use would be for projects such as a nationwide broadband system.
Budget 2026 calls for the long-term lease process to begin mostly next year with enabling legislation and the first airport operator by 2029. This suggests that each of the four airports will have its own P3 lease concession.
FAA to Retire Floppy Disks by 2028
Yes, that is an actual headline that appeared nationwide on November 7th. You can read more details at Gizmodo. FAA is replacing four ancient systems with a new display system called E-IDS. The agency hopes to install the replacement system at 435 sites by the end of 2028.
My Washington Post Letter to the Editor
In response to a good Washington Post editorial in support of air traffic reform, I wrote a letter to the editor explaining why the term “privatization” can be misleading to many people. It explained that ATC reform in nearly 100 countries would be better described as converting government ATC systems into user-funded ATC utilities.
Straight to Gate for SFO
Starting tomorrow, passengers on five leading airlines serving San Francisco International will be able to check in and clear security at the Sonoma County Airport. After checking in and TSA screening, they will take a secure bus to San Francisco International, where they will bypass TSA and go straight to their gate, while their luggage is delivered to their departure aircraft. Straight to Gate builds on the prototype that is operational for Boston Logan Airport. The service is called Straight to Gate, operated by Landline. Its Boston Logan Airport service was discussed in the June issue of this newsletter.
Searidge Digital Ramp at Hollywood Burbank Airport
In the newly opened terminal at BUR, a Digital Ramp solution devised by Searidge Technologies went live in mid-October. The system gives ramp controllers a comprehensive real-time view of all ramp and gate areas from a Virtual Ramp Control Room. The system is also linked with the airport’s ADS-B ground surveillance data. Ramp controllers have panoramic camera views of the entire ramp area.
Vinci Airports Launches Modernization of Two European Airports
In September, Vinci Airports announced a £500 million investment program at Edinburgh Airport in Scotland. The upgrades will take place over the next five years. And in October, Vinci announced a seven-year €380 million investment in France’s Lyon-Saint-Exupéry Airport. That project includes adding a new Terminal 2, scheduled to open by 2029.
More Than 2,500 Aircraft Have Autoland System
Ian Molyneaux reported for Aerotime that the Garmin Autoland system is now installed and flying on more than 2,500 general aviation aircraft. It is now installed on 15 aircraft models. Two recent certifications were on the HondaJet Elite II and the Embraer Phenom 300EV. Autoland can derive and implement the best flight plan for an emergency landing, and it is especially valuable if a solo pilot becomes unable to fly. It can also activate if it detects no pilot activity.
Phoenix Plans $4.5 Billion West Terminal
Aviation Pros reported that Phoenix Sky Harbor Airport is proceeding to finance and build a new West Terminal, costing $4.5 billion. It will be located on the airport’s west side, between Terminal 3 and Taxiway U. American will be the primary carrier using the new terminal. AA handles about 40% of Sky Harbor passengers.
SW Florida Airport Continues Major Expansion Project
In fast-growing Southwest Florida, the major airport has spent the past two years on an upgrade that is adding 14 gates. Southwest Florida International Airport (RSW) has more than a year still to go on this large-scale expansion. The project is reportedly the largest capital project in Lee County history.
SpaceX Planning Starship Launches from Cape Canaveral
Aviation Week (October 12-25, 2026) reported that SpaceX plans only one more launch of its huge Starship from Texas. After that, Starship will be launched from the Kennedy Space Center at Cape Canaveral. Two Starship launch facilities are under construction at the Cape. Longer term, as reported in the September issue of this newsletter, SpaceX plans a huge Starship launch complex on Pecan Island, Louisiana.
Space Force Interested in a Large-Cargo Starship
Politico Pro Space reported that the U.S. Space Force has expressed interest in a modified version of the SpaceX Starship. Instead of the “Pez-dispenser” equipment for inserting small satellites into orbits, the new version would require a large cargo bay for larger military payloads. The newsletter’s source was a former Space Force official.
NASA’s Isaacman Seeks to Send Mars Rover to the Moon
Politico Pro reported (July 31st) that NASA Administrator Jared Isaacman has proposed sending a spare Mars rover to the Moon, to save money. The rover is located at Jet Propulsion Laboratory in California and would have to be customized for the potential Moon mission.
Signature Aviation and UrbanV Announce Joint Venture
Aviation Pros reported that fixed-base operator Signature Aviation and vertiport developer UrbanV have created a joint venture to serve Advanced Air Mobility companies with support infrastructure for eVTOLs and other AAM customers. The joint venture was announced at the NBAA-BACE conference in October.
Philippines Reviewing Davao Airport P3 Proposal
Infralogic reported that the PPP Centre of the Philippines is reviewing an unsolicited proposal for a long-term public-private partnership for Davao Airport modernization. After review by the Transportation Department, the proposal will go to the Investment Coordination Committee and eventually to the Cabinet Committee. The approval process is limited to 120 days.
Air France Says Contrails Are Avoidable
Aviation Week reported (October 12-25) that an Air France project has determined that slight changes in flight plans can often avoid meteorological conditions that lead to the formation of contrails. In the project, out of 4,300 flights across the North Atlantic, the airline identified 245 with a high potential for climate impact via contrails and was able to re-route 130 of them.
“Almost every other nation—the UK, Ireland, France, Germany, Mexico—has separated air traffic services from its regulator. The US hasn’t. The FAA still sets the safety standards and provides the service, then grades itself on how well it did. As I always say, you cannot have the fox watching the chicken house…The thread running through all of it: the system is too big, too entrenched, and too conflicted to fix with new equipment and AI tools alone. It requires structural change—separating regulator from operator, building an honest safety culture, and bringing all stakeholders—airlines, military, regulators, and communities—to the same table.”
—Tom Lintner, Nobody’s Airspace, October 12, 2026
“The reasons why [it took 12 years after Europe to field US digital towers]? Bureaucracy, old guard, union issues—but if FAA can’t adopt this fairly straightforward technology any faster than 12 years, how will it keep pace with an AI tidal wave coming? And how will government have even a skeleton crew of employees who choose government service over millions of dollars in compensation with Silicon Valley?”
—David Hughes, email to Robert Poole, October 2, 2026
“The regrettable history [of ATC failures] didn’t stop [Secretary] Duffy from using the equipment failures to lobby Congress for more money. ‘This incident underscores the need for additional funding to modernize aging infrastructure and prevent disruption like this in the future,’ he said. No, it underscores why air traffic control should be privatized, as Canada has done with much success. This would free it from congressional meddling, enable it to make long-term investments, and impose much-needed accountability. America’s air traffic system is an international embarrassment. Why is no one in Washington embarrassed?”
—The Editorial Board, “Welcome to New York (Hours Late),” The Wall Street Journal, September 22, 2026