Four takeaways from the U.S. Census Bureau’s latest school finance data
Photo 23147767 © Joe Sohm | Dreamstime.com

Commentary

Four takeaways from the U.S. Census Bureau’s latest school finance data

With federal data from the 2022 school year now available, policymakers can better grasp how the COVID-19 pandemic affected public school budgets.

As public schools grapple with historic challenges—enrollment losses, learning recovery, fiscal cliffs, and others—it’s critical to examine the funding trends that will shape the future of K-12 budgets. With federal data from the 2022 school year now available, policymakers can better grasp how the COVID-19 pandemic affected public school budgets and what might lie ahead. Here are four key takeaways from the U.S. Census Bureau’s latest school finance data.

Public education funding is up by 34% per student in the last two decades.

Public education funding hit record levels in 2022, continuing its upward trajectory. Between 2002 and 2022, inflation-adjusted K-12 revenue increased by 34.2%, going from $14,088 per student to $18,911 per student. All states saw positive growth, including ten states with 50% or more increases. In 2022, the top spending states were New York ($35,902), New Jersey ($29,019), Connecticut ($28,363), Vermont ($27,338), and Pennsylvania ($24,917). Table 1 shows the inflation-adjusted revenue figures for all states.

Table 1: Inflation-Adjusted Revenue Per Student Growth (2002-2022)

Growth Rank2022 RankState20022022Growth
United States$14,088$18,91134.2%
11New York$19,791$35,90281.4%
27Illinois$14,309$23,04361.0%
39New Hampshire$14,184$22,73860.3%
411California$13,671$21,74859.1%
55Pennsylvania$15,824$24,91757.5%
617Washington$12,909$20,30957.3%
74Vermont$17,402$27,33857.1%
820North Dakota$12,049$18,86956.6%
923Louisiana$11,413$17,77055.7%
103Connecticut$18,809$28,36350.8%
1132Kentucky$11,175$16,24345.4%
1218Oregon$13,622$19,32941.9%
132New Jersey$20,794$29,01939.6%
1416Maine$14,822$20,56338.7%
158Rhode Island$16,435$22,76038.5%
1614Maryland$15,495$21,21636.9%
1710Wyoming$16,337$22,10235.3%
1843Tennessee$10,159$13,62834.1%
1948Mississippi$9,732$13,04934.1%
2026New Mexico$12,538$16,76533.7%
2112Delaware$16,330$21,71333.0%
2228Colorado$12,411$16,47732.8%
236Massachusetts$18,367$24,27432.2%
2435Montana$12,114$15,80530.5%
2513Alaska$16,397$21,31130.0%
2625South Carolina$13,196$17,11029.7%
2741Arkansas$11,051$14,26829.1%
2840Alabama$11,173$14,30028.0%
2921Minnesota$14,713$18,80727.8%
3015Hawaii$16,208$20,58427.0%
3127Virginia$13,296$16,73225.8%
3239Nevada$11,480$14,37625.2%
3334Kansas$12,845$15,92724.0%
3431Iowa$13,173$16,33124.0%
3549Utah$9,435$11,62323.2%
3636Missouri$12,828$15,75822.8%
3742South Dakota$11,546$14,17322.8%
3819Michigan$15,915$19,31821.4%
3922Ohio$15,356$18,33419.4%
4030Nebraska$13,752$16,35318.9%
4133West Virginia$13,539$15,94717.8%
4245Arizona$11,350$13,36017.7%
4347Oklahoma$11,116$13,08117.7%
4429Georgia$14,035$16,40116.9%
4538Texas$12,577$14,69616.8%
4644North Carolina$11,846$13,44813.5%
4746Florida$11,737$13,27513.1%
4824Wisconsin$15,446$17,28911.9%
4950Idaho$10,434$11,54010.6%
5037Indiana$14,378$15,3977.1%

Federal dollars have driven K-12 funding growth since the start of COVID-19.

Policy decisions during the COVID-19 pandemic had major school finance implications, so it’s important to consider funding trends since 2020. Nationwide, inflation-adjusted education funding grew by 7.4% per student between 2020 and 2022—about $1,300 per student. During this time, Louisiana (17.9%), California (17.2%), and Kentucky (16.5%) had the highest growth, with only Alaska, Delaware, and Kansas seeing declines, as shown in Figure 1.

But nearly all the $1,300 per student funding increase since the pandemic’s start—$1,245 per student—was due to a temporary spike in federal dollars. Congress sent $190 billion in K-12 relief aid to states through three separate packages, and all states saw substantial gains in federal funding that ranged from $457 per student (Kansas) to $1,650 per student (Kentucky). In total, federal funding growth exceeded $1,000 per student in 42 states. Table 2 includes federal funding growth data across states.

Figure 1: Inflation-Adjusted Funding Growth Per Student Since the Start of the COVID-19 Pandemic (2020-2022)

Inflation has erased gains in state and local education funding since 2020.

Federal funding has driven recent K-12 finance trends. But with federal relief aid expiring later this year, it's critical to examine what's happened with non-federal dollars since the pandemic's start. Table 2 compares growth in federal and non-federal revenue (non-federal dollars include funding from state and local sources). Rampant inflation has eaten into gains in non-federal funding, which comprises the bulk of dollars for public schools across the country.

Between 2020 and 2022, nominal non-federal funding grew by $1,485 per student but only $55 per student after adjusting for inflation. Overall, 20 states saw real increases in non-federal dollars, with five states exceeding $1,000 per student growth (California, New Jersey, Louisiana, New York, and Missouri) and four states exceeding $1,000 per student decline (Texas, Hawaii, Alaska, and Delaware).

For context, between 2018 and 2020, non-federal revenue went up nominally by $1,204 per student, resulting in a $769 increase in real terms. During this time, 43 states increased their inflation-adjusted non-federal funding per student. Had inflation stayed at its pre-pandemic level, non-federal funding would've gone up by roughly $938 per student between 2020 and 2022 rather than the $55 per student observed.

Table 2: Inflation-adjusted Funding Growth Per Student by Source (2020-2022)

Non-Federal Growth Per Student RankFederal Growth Per Student RankStateTotal GrowthNon-Federal Growth Per StudentFederal  Growth Per Student
United States$1,300$55$1,245
17California$3,184$1,691$1,493
230New Jersey$2,698$1,526$1,172
38Louisiana$2,694$1,217$1,477
432New York$2,222$1,057$1,164
533Missouri$2,162$1,021$1,141
641Oregon$1,960$947$1,012
71Kentucky$2,304$655$1,650
828Arizona$1,532$347$1,185
934Alabama$1,442$343$1,100
1037Virginia$1,386$298$1,089
1140Rhode Island$1,302$284$1,018
1242Maine$1,287$280$1,008
134Michigan$1,814$274$1,540
1424Vermont$1,494$258$1,237
1547New Mexico$985$244$741
1613Tennessee$1,600$218$1,382
1718Nevada$1,490$186$1,304
186North Carolina$1,620$123$1,497
1917South Carolina$1,408$62$1,346
2011Georgia$1,487$48$1,439
2149Utah$631-$71$702
2244Wisconsin$830-$100$930
2326Connecticut$1,095-$114$1,208
2445Indiana$742-$126$869
2548Colorado$586-$129$714
2636Illinois$905-$186$1,091
2720Oklahoma$1,071-$214$1,285
285Arkansas$1,302-$229$1,531
299Mississippi$1,238-$232$1,470
3022Massachusetts$951-$292$1,242
3143New Hampshire$670-$293$963
322Pennsylvania$1,322-$302$1,623
3335Idaho$794-$303$1,097
3421Wyoming$852-$407$1,259
3539Florida$640-$407$1,047
3638Iowa$643-$444$1,088
3714Washington$922-$455$1,377
3815Maryland$847-$509$1,357
3950Kansas-$65-$521$457
4046Nebraska$219-$597$816
4129South Dakota$569-$615$1,183
4216Ohio$724-$626$1,350
4312Montana$710-$725$1,435
4431West Virginia$421-$744$1,165
4523Minnesota$432-$808$1,240
463North Dakota$645-$975$1,620
4727Texas$66-$1,132$1,198
4819Hawaii$23-$1,280$1,302
4925Alaska-$356-$1,582$1,226
5010Delaware-$248-$1,699$1,452

Eight states have increased K-12 appropriations since 2020 despite substantial enrollment declines.

State funding formulas tie dollars to enrollment, so school districts lose funding when student counts fall. But this doesn't necessarily mean that state K-12 appropriations will also decline. Between 2020 and 2022, eight states increased inflation-adjusted education appropriations despite substantial enrollment losses. Notably, California increased total state funding by 6.6% despite losing 5.2% of its students. Put another way, California's public schools got an additional $3.8 billion even though they served 292,800 fewer students.

The interplay between enrollment, state funding formulas, and state appropriations will be important in the coming years as federal projections show enrollment will continue to fall until at least 2030. It's generally true that public schools lose funding when enrollment drops, but increases in state funding could offset these losses—especially in states that have generous hold harmless that protect against funding losses.

Figure 2:  States with K-12 Enrollment Declines and Inflation-adjusted State Funding Increases (2020-2022)

Conclusion

The U.S. Census Bureau’s latest school finance data illustrate an odd fiscal reality for public schools: despite record funding levels, many will have tight or shrinking budgets in the years ahead as they deal with challenges from things such as inflation, enrollment losses, and the expiration of federal COVID-19 relief aid. State and local policymakers must monitor these trends closely.